Section 351 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 12 AB(4) -- the SPECIFIED VIOLATIONS framework introduced FA 2022 enumerating specific breaches that empower PCIT/CIT to CANCEL trust's registration under s. 332 . Cancellation triggers…
351
ITA 2025 · Section 351
Section 351 — - SPECIFIED VIOLATIONS
Section 351 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 12AB(4) -- the SPECIFIED VIOLATIONS framework introduced FA 2022 enumerating specific breaches that empower PCIT/CIT to CANCEL trust's registration under s. 332. Cancellation triggers s. 352 ACCRETED INCOME EXIT TAX (potentially 35%+ on accumulated wealth). The provision establishes which compliance failures are SERIOUS enough to warrant registration cancellation vs lesser violations addressed by s. 353. Key categories: (a) commercial / non-charitable activity (s. 345 violations); (b) specific abuse / mismanagement; (c) anonymous donation non-compliance; (d) corpus / accumulation rule violations; (e) audit / return / form non-filing. Practitioner-grade rule: monitor compliance against specified-violations list; remedy promptly; appellate route ITAT direct.
STATUTORY ARCHITECTURE
SPECIFIED VIOLATIONS triggering registration cancellation: (I) APPLICATION FOR PURPOSE OTHER THAN REGISTERED OBJECTS: trust applying income for non-charitable / non-registered purpose; (II) BUSINESS / COMMERCIAL ACTIVITY violation under s. 345 (1961 s. 11(4A)) -- exceeding 20% gross-receipts limit OR not incidental to charitable object OR not business income utilised for objects; (III) NON-COMPLIANCE WITH SPECIFIED CONDITIONS at registration / approval stage; (IV) MISMANAGEMENT / DIVERSION OF FUNDS: persons specified in s. 13 (1961 s. 13) using trust funds for personal benefit; (V) NON-FILING OF RETURN / AUDIT REPORT for specified periods; (VI) VIOLATION OF S. 350 INVESTMENT RULES: trust funds in non-permitted instruments; (VII) ANONYMOUS DONATION non-compliance (s. 337 violation); (VIII) CORPUS / ACCUMULATION rule violations (ss. 339-343); (IX) FORM 10BD / 10BE FILING DEFAULTS (post FA 2020 framework). PROCEDURAL: PCIT issues show-cause; opportunity to be heard; cancellation order if violations established; appellate route ITAT direct (skip CIT(A)) within 60 days.
CONSEQUENCE -- s. 352 ACCRETED INCOME TAX
Cancellation under s. 351 triggers s. 352 (1961 s. 115TD) ACCRETED INCOME EXIT TAX: Accreted Income = FMV of net assets - corpus + specified additions / reductions; Tax: Maximum Marginal Rate (~35%+ effective). Substantial -- can wipe out lifetime accumulated wealth. STRATEGIC: prevent specified violation; if cancellation impending, strategic restructuring to qualifying transferee charity may preserve assets.
PRACTITIONER NOTES
(i) COMPLIANCE MONITORING -- annual review against specified-violation list; quarterly board oversight. (ii) S. 345 COMMERCIAL ACTIVITY -- 20% threshold; document business activity separately; ensure incidental / object-related. (iii) AUDIT REPORT (Form 10B / 10BB) -- mandatory; deadlines strict; compliance-first. (iv) RETURN-FILING DISCIPLINE (Form ITR-7) -- under s. 263(4A) / 1961 s. 139(4A). (v) FORM 10BD / 10BE -- post FA 2020; mandatory; non-filing = specified violation. (vi) PERSONAL-BENEFIT AVOIDANCE -- s. 13 / s. 353 -- trust persons cannot use trust assets personally; arms-length transactions. (vii) PCIT SHOW-CAUSE RESPONSE -- comprehensive submission; remedy if possible; preserve ITAT appeal.
CROSS-REFERENCES