BharatTax.co — Knowledge Portal
279

ITA 2025 · Section 279

Income Escaping Assessment

Section 279 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 147 -- the foundational provision authorising RE-OPENING OF ASSESSMENT for years where INCOME has ESCAPED ASSESSMENT. POST FA 2021 WATERSHED: the provision was substantially…

Section 279 — - INCOME ESCAPING ASSESSMENT

Section 279 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 147 -- the foundational provision authorising RE-OPENING OF ASSESSMENT for years where INCOME has ESCAPED ASSESSMENT. POST FA 2021 WATERSHED: the provision was substantially restructured replacing 'reason to believe' standard with 'INFORMATION SUGGESTING INCOME HAS ESCAPED ASSESSMENT' standard, with mandatory pre-notice procedure under s. 281 (1961 s. 148A). The new framework provides STRONGER PROCEDURAL SAFEGUARDS to assessee but allows broader reopening based on 'information' (DGIT-Inv specified information / tax-evasion-petitioned / etc.). Time-limits under s. 282 (1961 s. 149) progressively reduced for non-abnormal cases. Critical for tax-controversy practice -- many high-value assessments reopened under the FA 2021 framework.

FA 2021 WATERSHED REFORM

PRE-FA 2021: 'reason to believe' standard; AO subjective; broad reopening but heavy litigation on 'reason' validity. POST FA 2021: 'INFORMATION SUGGESTING INCOME HAS ESCAPED ASSESSMENT' -- specific information based standard. INFORMATION CATEGORIES: (a) Information from DGIT (Inv) -- intelligence-based; (b) Information from CBDT-prescribed sources; (c) Annual Information Statement (AIS) / Form 26AS / TIS-derived; (d) Cross-border information exchange (CRS / FATCA / DTAA Article 26); (e) Survey / search-derived (s. 247 / 253); (f) Audit objections raised by C&AG; (g) Court / tribunal observations / judicial findings.

PROCEDURAL FRAMEWORK

FA 2021 introduced MANDATORY 4-STEP PROCESS: (I) AO has information suggesting escape (s. 279); (II) PRE-NOTICE INQUIRY under s. 281 (1961 s. 148A): show-cause + assessee response; AO order whether to issue notice; (III) NOTICE under s. 280 (1961 s. 148): if AO concludes information valid, issues reassessment notice; (IV) REASSESSMENT under s. 270 procedure: scrutiny / faceless framework. TIME-LIMITS (s. 282 / 1961 s. 149): (a) 3 YEARS from end of relevant tax year -- normal cases; (b) 5 YEARS -- where escape > INR 50 lakh; (c) 10 YEARS -- search-cases / exceptional escape (FA 2024 reduced from 11 years post FA 2021). SANCTION (s. 284 / 1961 s. 151): senior authority approval (PCIT/CIT level for typical; PCCIT/CCIT for >5-year cases) MANDATORY before notice.

PRACTITIONER NOTES

(i) PRE-NOTICE PROCEDURE COMPLIANCE -- s. 281 mandatory; non-compliance renders subsequent notice void. (ii) RESPONSE QUALITY -- comprehensive response to s. 281 show-cause critical; documentary evidence; explain alleged escape. (iii) SANCTION VALIDATION -- check authority level approving notice (PCIT/CIT/PCCIT); incorrect-level sanction = invalid notice. (iv) TIME-LIMIT DEFENCE -- s. 282 limits strict; barred-by-time defence powerful. (v) ESCAPE QUANTUM CHECK -- INR 50 lakh threshold for 5-year window crucial. (vi) WRIT JURISDICTION -- early-stage challenge to s. 281 / 280 notices via writ at HC; before reassessment proceeds. (vii) NATURAL JUSTICE -- show-cause adequate / personal hearing / specific allegations; lacuna creates challenge basis.

CROSS-REFERENCES

  • Section 280 -- Notice for escaped assessment.
  • Section 281 -- Pre-notice procedure (FA 2021).
  • Section 282 -- Time-limit for notice.
  • Section 283 -- Other provisions on escaped assessment.
  • Section 284 -- Sanction for notice.
  • Section 270 -- Assessment (reassessment via).
  • Section 286 -- Time-limit for reassessment completion.
  • Section 247 -- Search and seizure (10-year window trigger).
  • Constitutional Article 226 -- writ jurisdiction.