Section 275 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 144C -- the DISPUTE RESOLUTION PANEL (DRP) framework, specifically targeting eligible-assessee cases including: (a) any person in whose case the variation arises as a consequence of the Transfer…
275
ITA 2025 · Section 275
Section 275 — REFERENCE TO DISPUTE RESOLUTION PANEL
Section 275 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 144C -- the DISPUTE RESOLUTION PANEL (DRP) framework, specifically targeting eligible-assessee cases including: (a) any person in whose case the variation arises as a consequence of the Transfer Pricing Officer's order under s. 166(6); (b) any non-resident (not being a company) or any FOREIGN COMPANY (sub-s. (17)(b)); in either case where the AO proposes a VARIATION prejudicial to the assessee. The provision establishes a SPECIALISED PRE-ASSESSMENT REVIEW BOARD comprising 3 senior-level CITs (Pr CIT / CIT level) at major centres (Mumbai / Delhi / Chennai / Kolkata / Bangalore / Ahmedabad / Hyderabad). DRP issues binding directions to AO; AO must follow. Assessee gets specialised review WITHOUT going to CIT(A); decisions can be challenged at ITAT directly. The provision is critical for high-stakes TP / international tax cases; significantly improves dispute resolution speed compared to traditional appellate channels.
STATUTORY ARCHITECTURE
ELIGIBLE ASSESSEE (sub-s. (17)(b)): (a) Any person in whose case the variation arises as a consequence of the TPO's order under s. 166(6) (TP-determined ALP); OR (b) Any non-resident (not being a company), or any FOREIGN COMPANY. Persons referred to in s. 292(1) and other persons referred to in s. 295 (search cases) are excluded (sub-s. (18)). PROCESS: (I) AO PASSES DRAFT ASSESSMENT ORDER (NOT FINAL); (II) Assessee receives draft order; 30-day objection window; (III) Assessee can: (a) ACCEPT draft -- AO finalises; OR (b) FILE OBJECTIONS with DRP within 30 days; (IV) DRP composed of 3 senior officers (PCIT/CIT level); meets at major centres; (V) DRP examines objections; calls for AO's response; may call assessee for personal hearing; (VI) DRP issues DIRECTIONS to AO -- BINDING on the AO (sub-s. (11)); (VII) AO finalises assessment per DRP directions WITHIN 1 MONTH from the end of the month in which the directions are received (sub-s. (14)); (VIII) DRP must complete within 9 MONTHS from end of month draft order issued. DRP DIRECTIONS POWERS: confirm / reduce / enhance variation (sub-s. (8)); the power to enhance extends to any matter arising out of the assessment proceedings relating to the draft order, even if the assessee did not raise it (sub-s. (9)); the DRP cannot set aside a proposed variation or direct further enquiry and passing of the assessment order.
APPELLATE ROUTE POST-DRP
Final assessment per DRP directions APPEALABLE DIRECTLY TO ITAT (skip CIT(A) under s. 357). Two strategic implications: (i) FASTER RESOLUTION -- typical timeline 2-3 years from objection to ITAT decision; vs traditional CIT(A) + ITAT route 4-6 years; (ii) NO CIT(A) FILTERING -- ITAT first appellate; the assessee appeals under s. 362(1)(d). PRACTICAL POINTS: for high-stakes TP / international cases, the DRP route is often chosen over the conventional appellate route. Objections are filed within 30 days.
CASE LAW / DRP DECISIONS
(i) PCIT v. Vodafone India Services (Bom HC, 2014) -- DRP framework applies; foreign company status. (ii) Maruti Suzuki India v. CIT (Del HC) -- AMP TP cases via DRP. (iii) Various ITAT decisions on DRP procedural fairness. (iv) DRP statistics show 70-80% partial / full relief in eligible cases.
PRACTICAL POINTS
(i) DRAFT ORDER -- received on the e-portal; the 30-day objection window is strict. (ii) OBJECTION DOCUMENTATION -- DRP relies heavily on the quality of the objections. (iii) PERSONAL HEARING REQUEST -- DRP allows VC hearing on request; useful for complex factual matters. (iv) DRP CHOICE FOR FOREIGN CO -- automatic eligibility as a foreign company. (v) ITAT APPEAL -- post-DRP final order, ITAT route within two months from the end of the month in which the order is communicated (s. 362(3)).
CROSS-REFERENCES