BharatTax.co — Knowledge Portal
28

ITA 2025 · Section 28

Rent Rates Taxes Repairs Insurance

Section 28 prescribes deduction for rent, rates, taxes, current repairs, and insurance premiums on premises / plant & machinery / furniture used for business. The substantive rule: revenue expenditure deductible; capital expenditure…

Section 28 — RENT, RATES, TAXES, REPAIRS AND INSURANCE

Section 28 prescribes deduction for rent, rates, taxes, current repairs, and insurance premiums on premises / plant & machinery / furniture used for business. The substantive rule: revenue expenditure deductible; capital expenditure (e.g., major reconstruction) is NOT — that goes to depreciation u/s 33.

JUDICIAL EVOLUTION — Current vs. Capital Repairs

Empire Jute Co. Ltd. v. CIT, (1980) 124 ITR 1 (SC) — the foundational distinction: revenue expenditure preserves the asset's usefulness; capital expenditure enhances the asset's character or extends its life. Routine maintenance, painting, leak repairs are revenue; major reconstruction, conversion to alternative use, or significant capacity enhancement are capital.

HELD: If the expenditure is for the initiation of the business or for extension of the business or for substantial replacement of equipment, the expenditure is in the nature of capital expenditure. If it is to facilitate the carrying on of the business or for current repair, it is revenue. (per Empire Jute ¶ 14).

PLANNING NOTES

(i) Document each repair invoice with description and impact analysis (preservation vs. enhancement); cite Empire Jute for revenue characterisation. (ii) Insurance premium for plant / machinery / building IS deductible; insurance for goods-in-transit (stock) is also revenue. (iii) For leased premises, document the lessor's obligation under the lease deed to confirm deductibility falls in lessee's hands.

CROSS-REFERENCES

  • Section 33 — Depreciation (capital expenditure routes here).
  • Section 35 — Amounts not deductible.
  • Section 36 — Cash payment / disallowances.