Section 58 consolidates the three presumptive-tax regimes of the 1961 Act — s. 44 AD (small business; 6%/8% of turnover up to ₹2 cr / ₹3 cr); s. 44 AE (transporters; ≤ 10 goods carriages, ₹1000/ton or ₹7500/vehicle); and s. 44 ADA…
58
ITA 2025 · Section 58
Section 58 — PRESUMPTIVE TAXATION (44AD / 44ADA / 44AE EQUIVALENT)
Section 58 consolidates the three presumptive-tax regimes of the 1961 Act — s. 44AD (small business; 6%/8% of turnover up to ₹2 cr / ₹3 cr); s. 44AE (transporters; ≤ 10 goods carriages, ₹1000/ton or ₹7500/vehicle); and s. 44ADA (specified profession; 50% of gross receipts up to ₹50 lakh / ₹75 lakh) — into a single Table-driven dispensation. Sub-section (1) is non-obstante: it overrides ss. 26-54 to the extent of conflict for specified businesses / professions. Audit-and-records relief, advance-tax single-instalment relief (15-March), and consequence of opting-out are preserved.
STATUTORY ARCHITECTURE
Sub-section (1) — non-obstante override of ss. 26-54 for specified businesses / professions in the Table. Sub-section (2) — three-row Table is the substantive computation engine. Sub-section (3) — books / audit relief: presumptive assessees not required to maintain books u/s 62(2) or get audit u/s 63 if presumptive declared. Sub-section (4) — advance-tax single-instalment by 15-March (s. 408 equivalent of 1961 s. 211). Sub-section (5) onwards — opt-out consequences: 5-year lockout from re-electing s. 58 once opted out and books-and-audit obligation triggered for those years. Sub-section (10) onwards — eligibility definitions: 'eligible assessee' (resident individual / HUF / firm — not LLP), no Chapter VIII-C deduction, no specified-profession (s. 62(4)), no commission / brokerage, no agency.
THRESHOLDS & BANKING-RECEIPT INCENTIVE
For Sl. No. 1: turnover up to ₹2 crore — full presumptive eligibility; up to ₹3 crore IF cash-receipts ≤ 5% of total turnover. Within the eligible turnover, 6% rate applies on banking-channel / online receipts and 8% on the rest. For Sl. No. 3: gross receipts up to ₹50 lakh — full eligibility; up to ₹75 lakh IF cash-receipts ≤ 5% of gross receipts. The banking-channel incentive (6% v. 8%) drives digitisation among small businesses.
CASE LAW
CIT v. Sri Padmavathi Srinivasa Cotton Ginning Factory (AP HC) — turnover-test reckoned per books, not gross receipts. Nand Lal Popli v. DCIT (ITAT) — opt-in to s. 44AD does not preclude challenge to addition u/s 68 / 69 if cash-deposits unexplained. Pandit Vijay Kumar Sharma v. ITO (ITAT Cuttack) — once 44AD opted, AO cannot make additions for low net-profit unless books rejected u/s 145(3).
PLANNING NOTES
(i) For small-business clients (turnover ≤ ₹3 cr), evaluate s. 58(2) Sl. No. 1 vs. regular books-and-audit annually — if actual NP < 6% / 8%, consider opt-out (but lockout for 5 years). (ii) For professionals (CA / lawyer / doctor / architect / interior designer / film artist) with gross receipts ≤ ₹75 lakh, s. 58(2) Sl. No. 3 is typically beneficial — 50% deemed NP. (iii) For transporters owning ≤ 10 goods-carriages, s. 58(2) Sl. No. 2 — ₹7,500 / vehicle / month or ₹1,000 / ton / month for HGVs. Maintain RC / GVW records. (iv) Cash-receipt 5% threshold — meticulous documentation of banking-channel receipts is critical; minor cash overshoot disqualifies entire presumptive election. (v) Salary-and-interest paid to partners — under 1961, allowed as deduction post presumptive 8% / 6%; under s. 58, check sub-clauses for partnership-firm-specific allowance.
CROSS-REFERENCES