Section 36 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 40A — covering excessive or unreasonable payments to specified persons, payments exceeding ₹10,000 in a day otherwise than through specified banking or online mode, and marked to market…
36
ITA 2025 · Section 36
Section 36 — EXPENSES OR PAYMENTS NOT DEDUCTIBLE
Section 36 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 40A — covering excessive or unreasonable payments to specified persons, payments exceeding ₹10,000 in a day otherwise than through specified banking or online mode (including later payment of a liability allowed earlier), and marked to market or other expected losses. Gratuity provisions and contributions to non-statutory funds, dealt with by 1961 s. 40A(7) and (9), are now in s. 29(2) and (3), not in s. 36. The most-litigated sub-section: payment > ₹10,000 (₹35,000 for plying, hiring or leasing goods carriages) in a day otherwise than through specified banking or online mode — disallowance under s. 36(4) (s. 40A(3) of 1961 Act).
STATUTORY ARCHITECTURE
Section 36 has effect irrespective of the other provisions on computing business income (sub-s. (1)) and has four operative limbs: (1) payments to specified persons — so much as the Assessing Officer considers excessive or unreasonable, having regard to fair market value, the legitimate needs of the business or the benefit derived, is disallowed (s. 36(2); 'specified person' and 'substantial interest', at 20 per cent, are defined in sub-s. (3)); (2) a payment exceeding ₹10,000 in a day to a person otherwise than through specified banking or online mode — the expenditure is disallowed (s. 36(4)); (3) a liability allowed in an earlier year and paid later in that way — the payment is deemed income of the year of payment (s. 36(5)); the limit is ₹35,000 for plying, hiring or leasing goods carriages (sub-s. (6)), with prescribed exceptions (sub-s. (7)); (4) marked to market or other expected loss — not deductible except as allowable under s. 32(1)(h) (sub-s. (9)). Gratuity provisions and contributions to non-statutory funds are dealt with in s. 29(2) and (3), not here.
JUDICIAL EVOLUTION — Cash Payment Bar (Attar Singh Gurmukh Singh)
Attar Singh Gurmukh Singh v. ITO, (1991) 191 ITR 667 (SC) — upheld constitutional validity of s. 40A(3) [now s. 36(4) of 2025 Act]. The disallowance is not penal but a regulatory measure to channel transactions through banking system. Rule 6DD (1962 Rules) exceptions (banking holiday, agricultural producer, no banking facility) provide statutory safety-valves.
HELD: Section 40A(3) of the Act and Rule 6DD of the Rules are intended to regulate business transactions and to prevent the use of unaccounted money or reduce the chances to use black money for business transactions. The provisions are aimed at creating an offence with civil consequences only — not penal. (per Attar Singh Gurmukh Singh ¶ 12).
JUDICIAL EVOLUTION — Related-Party Reasonableness (s. 40A(2))
CIT v. Glaxo SmithKline Asia (P.) Ltd., (2010) 195 Taxman 35 (SC) — for related-party expenditure, the AO must demonstrate that the payment is excessive having regard to FAIR MARKET VALUE; mere relationship with payee is insufficient. Onus on Department to establish excessiveness.
DEPARTMENTAL PRACTICE
Income-tax Rules, 2026 r. 26 (formerly r. 6DD of the 1962 Rules) — exceptions to s. 36(4) cash-payment disallowance (banking holiday, agricultural payment to producer, transport contractor with no banking facility at site, etc.). Form No. 26 (formerly Form 3CD Item 21(d)) — auditor's reporting on s. 36 disallowances. Form No. 26 (formerly Form 3CD Item 23) — auditor's reporting on related-party transactions u/s 36(2) read with s. 36(3).
PRACTICAL POINTS & LITIGATION DEFENCE
(i) Business expenditure paid to a person in a day in excess of ₹10,000 otherwise than through specified banking or online mode is disallowed u/s 36(4) — automatically, unless a Rule 26 exception applies. (ii) For genuine cash-only scenarios (e.g., payment to truck driver at remote site), Rule 26 applicability rests on evidence — bounce-cheque / no-banking-facility evidence. (iii) For related-party payments, arm's-length pricing (TP-equivalent analysis) supports the claim; Glaxo SmithKline is cited for the AO having to establish excessiveness. (iv) Gratuity is deductible on contribution to an APPROVED fund; ad-hoc provisions or non-approved fund contributions are disallowed under s. 29(2) and (3), not s. 36.
CROSS-REFERENCES