BharatTax.co — Knowledge Portal
57

ITA 2025 · Section 57

Construction and Service Contracts Revenue Recognition

Chapter IV — Computation of Total IncomeITA 2025Tax year 2026-27 onward

Section 57 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 43CB. It mandates Percentage-of-Completion Method (PoCM) for construction contracts and long-duration service contracts (> 90 days), and Project-Completion Method for short-duration service…

Section 57 — REVENUE RECOGNITION FOR CONSTRUCTION & SERVICE CONTRACTS

Section 57 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 43CB. It mandates Percentage-of-Completion Method (PoCM) for construction contracts and long-duration service contracts (> 90 days), and Project-Completion Method for short-duration service contracts (≤ 90 days). The provision is an ICDS-anchor: PoCM must be applied per ICDS notified u/s 276(2) (1961 ICDS-III for construction; ICDS-IV for revenue recognition). It overrides AS-7 / Ind AS-115 deviations to the extent the latter conflict.

STATUTORY ARCHITECTURE

Section 57 is a method-of-accounting prescription, overriding general accrual / accounting choices. PoCM percentage must be measured per ICDS-III — surveys, costs-incurred-to-date / total-estimated-costs, or technical estimate. For service contracts, the 90-day duration test triggers different methods: short contracts use Completed-Contract; long use PoCM. Where service involves indeterminate number of acts over a fixed period (e.g., AMC contracts), straight-line recognition over the period is mandated.

RETENTION MONEY

Retention money is the part of the contract value withheld by the contractee, typically until the defect-liability period expires. Sub-section (3)(a) provides that, for the percentage of completion, project completion and straight line methods, the contract revenue includes retention money. Sub-section (3)(b) provides that contract costs are not reduced by incidental income in the nature of interest, dividends or capital gains.

CASE LAW

CIT v. Bilahari Investment P. Ltd (SC) — Project-Completion Method permissible for chit funds; not displaced by PoCM unless statute mandates. CIT v. Manish Buildwell P. Ltd (Del HC) — real-estate developer's PoCM upheld where consistent with AS-7 / ICDS. ACIT v. Mahindra Holidays & Resorts India Ltd (ITAT Chennai) — VOM membership-fee — substantial-services-rendered method upheld.

PRACTICAL POINTS

(i) For EPC contractors, EPC-developers, and infrastructure SPVs, PoCM measurement follows ICDS-III — the input-cost ratio is the most robust measure. (ii) Retention money: the contractor's certified-but-retained amounts form part of contract revenue in the PoCM computation (sub-s. (3)(a)). (iii) For service contracts straddling the 90-day boundary, the duration (start-date / end-date / extensions) decides the treatment. (iv) Consistency requirement: a method chosen for a contract type is applied across years.

CROSS-REFERENCES

  • Section 276(2) — ICDS notification source.
  • ICDS-III — Construction Contracts.
  • ICDS-IV — Revenue Recognition.
  • AS-7 / Ind AS-115 — Accounting Standards (subordinate to s. 57).