Section 44 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 35 D -- the 5-year amortisation regime for PRE-COMMENCEMENT and EXTENSION-OF-UNDERTAKING preliminary expenses. Pre-1976, such expenses were treated as enduring-benefit capital…
44
ITA 2025 · Section 44
Section 44 — - AMORTISATION OF CERTAIN PRELIMINARY EXPENSES
Section 44 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 35D -- the 5-year amortisation regime for PRE-COMMENCEMENT and EXTENSION-OF-UNDERTAKING preliminary expenses. Pre-1976, such expenses were treated as enduring-benefit capital expenditure (CIT v. Coal Shipments SC, 1971) and entirely disallowed; FA 1976 introduced a partial relief through 1/5 amortisation over 5 tax years; now codified in 2025 Act as s. 44. NINE sub-sections cover: (1) eligibility / start-of-amortisation; (2) covered expenditure types; (3) prescribed-form statement; (4) 5% project-cost / capital-employed cap; (5) definitions; (6) audit requirement for non-corporates; (7) amalgamation continuity; (8) demerger continuity; (9) anti-double-deduction. Practitioner-grade rule: every start-up's pre-incorporation cost / new-unit-set-up cost should be tested for s. 44 amortisation -- often misclassified as 'organisational expense' and lost.
STATUTORY ARCHITECTURE
Section 44 operates in two trigger-modes -- PRE-COMMENCEMENT (clause 1(a)) and EXTENSION OF UNDERTAKING / NEW UNIT (clause 1(b)). ELIGIBLE ASSESSEE: Indian company OR resident person other than company. Foreign companies / non-resident proprietorship -- NOT eligible. Co-operative societies -- NOT in opening words BUT see audit-requirement carve-out under sub-s. (6) which excludes co-op societies (suggesting they ARE eligible without audit certificate). MECHANISM: 1/5 of expenditure deducted in EACH of FIVE consecutive tax years starting with: (i) tax year of business commencement [for clause (a)]; OR (ii) tax year of extension completion / new unit commercial operation [for clause (b)]. QUANTIFICATION CAP (sub-s. 4): aggregate expenditure deductible cannot exceed 5% of: (a) cost of project; OR (b) capital employed in business of company [Indian companies only -- option]. Practitioner trip: while expenditure may exceed 5% cap, only 5% is deductible -- the balance is lost (no carry-forward to later years). Plan project capitalisation accordingly.
SUB-SECTION (2) -- COVERED EXPENDITURE TYPES
Four enumerated categories: (a) PROJECT-DEVELOPMENT expenses: feasibility report; project report; market survey or other necessary survey; engineering services for the business. These cover pre-investment due diligence and engineering-design phase. (b) LEGAL CHARGES for drafting AGREEMENTS between assessee and any other person related to setting up or conducting the business -- e.g., shareholders agreement, supply contracts, lease deed, JV agreement, technology licence drafting. (c) COMPANY-SPECIFIC (in addition to a, b): (i) drafting and printing MEMORANDUM and ARTICLES OF ASSOCIATION; (ii) ROC fees for company registration under Companies Act 2013; (iii) IPO / public-issue expenditure: underwriting commission, brokerage, drafting / typing / printing / advertisement of prospectus. (d) other prescribed items (Rule-prescribed; not eligible for any other deduction provision). Common practitioner mistakes: (a) treating these as 'goodwill' or 'capital reserve' (Schedule III treatment) and forgetting tax claim; (b) classifying engineering-design fees of plant as preliminary expense vs cost-of-asset (latter benefits from depreciation only).
SUB-SECTION (4) -- THE 5% CAP
5% cap applies to AGGREGATE of expenditure under sub-s. (2). Two bases (option-based for INDIAN COMPANY; non-co. assessees use only project-cost basis): (a) COST OF PROJECT = actual cost of fixed assets (land / buildings / leaseholds / plant / machinery / furniture / fittings / railway sidings + land-and-building development), as per books on last day of: (i) commencement-year [clause 1(a)]; OR (ii) extension-completion / new-unit-operation year [clause 1(b)] -- only for assets attributable to extension / new unit. (b) CAPITAL EMPLOYED [INDIAN CO. ONLY] = aggregate of issued share capital + debentures + long-term borrowings, as on same dates. Long-term borrowings (sub-s. 5(c)): (i) borrowings from Govt / IFCI / financial institution under s. 32(e) / banking institution; (ii) FOREIGN borrowings for purchase of capital plant outside India with tenure >= 7 years. Practitioner: Indian companies typically have higher capital-employed than project-cost (gearing ratio); choose capital-employed basis for higher cap. Non-corporate proprietors / partnerships limited to project-cost basis. Worked example: Indian co. project cost INR 50 crore; capital employed INR 100 crore; preliminary expenses INR 8 crore. Project-cost cap: 5% × 50 = INR 2.5 crore. Capital-employed cap: 5% × 100 = INR 5 crore. Choose capital-employed -- claim INR 5 crore over 5 years (INR 1 crore per year). Excess INR 3 crore lost.
SUB-SECTION (6) -- AUDIT REQUIREMENT
For NON-CORPORATE, NON-CO-OP-SOCIETY assessees (i.e., individual / firm / LLP), deduction is admissible only if: (a) accounts of years in which expenditure incurred have been AUDITED by an accountant before specified date in s. 63 (tax audit threshold provisions); (b) audit report furnished for FIRST YEAR of deduction claim. Effectively requires CA-certified audit even if assessee is below tax-audit threshold. Practitioner: extra compliance burden for proprietorships / firms; ensure audit BEFORE return-filing for first claim year.
SUB-SECTIONS (7) AND (8) -- AMALGAMATION / DEMERGER CONTINUITY
Where eligible Indian company's undertaking is transferred BEFORE EXPIRY of 5 years to another Indian company in: (a) Amalgamation -- amalgamating co. gets NO deduction in year of amalgamation; amalgamated co. continues amortisation from where amalgamating co. left off. (b) Demerger -- demerged co. gets NO deduction in year of demerger; resulting co. continues. Effect: c/f of unfinished amortisation seamlessly through tax-neutral M&A. Coordinated with s. 70(1)(e) and (j) tax-neutrality. The 5-year amortisation clock continues unbroken across the corporate event.
SUB-SECTION (9) -- ANTI-DOUBLE-DEDUCTION
Once a deduction is claimed under s. 44 for any expenditure, NO deduction allowed for the SAME expenditure under any other provision of this Act in same or any other tax year. Prevents double-dipping (e.g., claiming legal-fees both under s. 44 amortisation AND s. 28 / s. 34 deduction). Practitioner: maintain expense-by-expense ledger marking s. 44 claim; cross-check against s. 28/32/34/45 to prevent overlap.
CASE LAW -- LEADING DECISIONS
(i) CIT v. Bombay Steam Navigation Co (P) Ltd (SC, 1965) -- preliminary expenses pre-1976; foundational on enduring-benefit character. (ii) Brooke Bond India Ltd v. CIT (SC, 1997, 225 ITR 798) -- pre-FA 1995, IPO expenses fell outside s. 35D; legislatively addressed by clause (c)(iii). (iii) Punjab State Industrial Development Corporation v. CIT (SC, 1997, 225 ITR 792) -- shares-issue expenses analysed; clause (c)(iii) origin. (iv) ITAT precedents: Asea Brown Boveri (Bom HC) -- engineering services scope; Reliance Industries -- project cost vs capital employed cap optimisation. (v) Cadbury India Ltd v. ACIT (Bom HC) -- amalgamation continuity under sub-s. (7). (vi) Goodlas Nerolac Paints v. CIT -- legal charges scope; agreement-related vs general legal expense distinction. (vii) Nimbus Communications Ltd v. ACIT (ITAT Mumbai) -- 5% cap calculation methodology.
PLANNING NOTES (SEVEN AREAS)
(i) PRE-INCORPORATION TRACKING -- maintain ledger from concept stage; classify expenses into sub-s. (2) categories vs other capital / revenue. Misclassification often loses the s. 44 deduction. (ii) PROJECT-COST VS CAPITAL-EMPLOYED CAP -- model both at end of commencement year; choose higher base for Indian companies; document the option-exercise via board resolution. (iii) IPO COSTS (clause c(iii)) -- pair with SEBI / merchant banker invoices; underwriting commission is the largest line-item; ensure not also claimed under s. 35DD (amalgamation expenses). (iv) NON-CORPORATE AUDIT (sub-s. 6) -- engage CA early; audit report covers expenditure-year accounts even if below tax-audit threshold under general s. 63. (v) M&A CONTINUITY -- pre-amalgamation pending amortisation flows to amalgamated co.; ensure schedule update in transferee's tax computation. (vi) ANTI-DOUBLE-DEDUCTION -- annual reconciliation of s. 44 claim with all other deduction provisions; ITAT precedents flag overlap routinely. (vii) FOREIGN BORROWINGS (sub-s. 5(c)(ii)) -- only 7+ year tenure capital-plant borrowings count; review ECB documentation for tenure validation.
CROSS-REFERENCES