BharatTax.co — Knowledge Portal
33

ITA 2025 · Section 33

Depreciation

Section 33 is the depreciation provision — the most-litigated computational rule in PGBP. It extends to four asset classes: buildings, plant, machinery, and furniture (tangible); plus intangible assets (know-how, patents, trademarks)…

Section 33 — DEDUCTION FOR DEPRECIATION

Section 33 is the depreciation provision — the most-litigated computational rule in PGBP. It extends to four asset classes: buildings, plant, machinery, and furniture (tangible); plus intangible assets (know-how, patents, trademarks) acquired post 1-4-1998. The rates are prescribed by Income-tax Rules, 2026 r. 96 read with Schedule III. Additional depreciation @ 20% for new manufacturing plant & machinery is preserved.

STATUTORY ARCHITECTURE

Section 33 establishes the WDV (written-down value) method as the default depreciation methodology, with the block-of-assets concept (FA 1986) governing computation. Each asset class with same depreciation rate forms a 'block'; additions / sales adjust the block's WDV, and depreciation is charged on the block-WDV at the prescribed rate. Power-generation undertakings have the option for SLM (straight-line method) at percentages in Income-tax Rules, 2026 Appendix IA. Once exercised, the SLM election is irrevocable for the life of the asset.

STATUTORY ARCHITECTURE — Depreciation Rates (Rule 96 + Schedule III)

Buildings: 5% (residential) / 10% (non-residential / commercial), 40% (purely temporary erections). Furniture & Fittings: 10%. Plant & Machinery: 15% (general); 30% (specified machinery, motor vehicles for hire); 40% (computer hardware/software, energy-saving devices); 60-100% (R&D / pollution-control / specific environment-protection). Intangible assets (know-how, patents, trademarks): 25%. Ships and aircraft: 20% (with class-specific variations). Specified plant & machinery (post 1-4-2017 acquired): max rate capped at 40% (FA 2017 amendment).

JUDICIAL EVOLUTION — Functional Test for 'Plant' (Taj Mahal Hotel)

The leading authority is CIT v. Taj Mahal Hotel, (1971) 82 ITR 44 (SC), where the Supreme Court ruled that 'plant' has a wide meaning and includes any apparatus used by a businessman for carrying on his business — including sanitary fittings in a hotel.

HELD: The word 'plant' in its ordinary sense includes whatever apparatus is used by a businessman for carrying on his business. Sanitary and pipeline fittings in a hotel are 'plant' as they constitute the apparatus through which the hotel-keeper renders services. (per Taj Mahal Hotel ¶ 6).

JUDICIAL EVOLUTION — Building Exclusion (Anand Theatres + Karnataka Power)

CIT v. Anand Theatres, (2000) 244 ITR 192 (SC) — cinema / hotel building IS NOT plant for depreciation, however specially designed. The premises is the SITUS, not the apparatus. FA 2003 codified the building exclusion in Explanation 1 to s. 43(3) (now s. 33 Explanation) with retrospective effect from 1-4-1961.

CIT v. Karnataka Power Corporation Ltd., (2001) 247 ITR 268 (SC) — READ DOWN of Anand Theatres — generating-station building functionally integrated with apparatus may still qualify as plant. Functional test is determinative for sector-specific apparatus-buildings.

JUDICIAL EVOLUTION — Intangible Assets (Scientific Engineering)

Scientific Engineering House (P.) Ltd. v. CIT, (1986) 157 ITR 86 (SC) — drawings, designs, charts, plans (know-how) are 'plant' for depreciation. Foundation for the post-FA-1998 intangible-asset depreciation regime under s. 32(1)(ii) [now s. 33].

JUDICIAL EVOLUTION — Goodwill (Smifs Securities — Pre-FA 2021)

CIT v. Smifs Securities Ltd., (2012) 348 ITR 302 (SC) — goodwill arising on amalgamation IS depreciable as 'any other business or commercial right of similar nature'. FA 2021 reversed this position by adding 'goodwill' as a specified excluded item from the intangible-asset depreciation regime; goodwill no longer depreciable from AY 2021-22 onwards.

JUDICIAL EVOLUTION — Slump-Sale Goodwill Cost (Hindustan Coca-Cola)

For pre-FA 2021 amalgamations and slump sales, goodwill cost determination follows the SC ratio in slump-sale jurisprudence — cost is the consideration allocated to goodwill in the scheme. Post-FA 2021, even slump-sale goodwill is non-depreciable.

DEPARTMENTAL PRACTICE

Income-tax Rules, 2026 r. 96 + Schedule III — depreciation rate table by asset class. Rule 96(1A) — power generation undertakings option for SLM (Appendix IA percentages). Form 3CD Item 18 — auditor's reporting on depreciation computation, additions/disposals, additional depreciation. Block-of-assets reconciliation in Schedule DEP of ITR-3/5/6 — opening WDV → additions → disposals → closing WDV → depreciation charge.

PLANNING NOTES & LITIGATION DEFENCE

(i) For specialised industrial structures (cold storage, gas-storage tank, telecom tower, wind-turbine foundation), evaluate Karnataka Power-type plant claim with engineering certificate. (ii) For hotel / cinema / hospital buildings, accept building-rate depreciation — Anand Theatres forecloses plant classification. (iii) For lift, escalator, electrical fittings, plumbing — these are 'plant' attached to a building, depreciable at plant rate (10%-15%) if separately invoiced and identified. (iv) Maintain detailed asset master with engineering certification of plant character — critical for s. 167/168 scrutiny defence. (v) For amalgamation / slump-sale post-FA 2021, do NOT claim goodwill depreciation; route any 'know-how' or 'distribution network' separately under intangible-asset class. (vi) For 50%-rate assets (used < 180 days), verify date of put-to-use; cite circumstantial evidence (commissioning report, employment of personnel, electricity connection).

CROSS-REFERENCES

  • Section 26 — PGBP charge.
  • Section 41 — Written down value of depreciable asset.
  • Section 39 — Computation of actual cost.
  • Section 67 — Capital gains charge (depreciable asset transfer routes through s. 50).
  • Income-tax Rules, 2026 r. 96 + Schedule III — depreciation rates by asset class.
  • Form 3CD Item 18 — auditor's reporting.