BharatTax.co — Knowledge Portal
87

ITA 2025 · Section 87

Industrial Shift Urban to Non-Urban

Section 87 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 54 G -- a TARGETED RELIEF for industrial undertakings shifting from URBAN AREAS to non-urban areas (decongestion / decentralisation policy intent). The provision allows business…

Section 87 — - CG ON SHIFTING OF INDUSTRIAL UNDERTAKING FROM URBAN AREA

Section 87 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 54G -- a TARGETED RELIEF for industrial undertakings shifting from URBAN AREAS to non-urban areas (decongestion / decentralisation policy intent). The provision allows business assessees (companies / firms / individuals operating industrial undertakings) to roll over CG arising from transfer of plant / machinery / building / land used for the urban industrial unit into corresponding investments in the new non-urban location. FIVE sub-sections cover: (1) eligibility / four expenditure heads / 1-year-before / 3-year-after window / cost-vs-CG mechanics; (2) CGAS deposit; (3) deemed cost; (4) unutilised charge in 3-year-expiry year; (5) 'urban area' definition (municipal-corporation / municipality CG-notified having regard to population / industry-concentration / planning need). Distinct from s. 82 / s. 86 (residential-house regimes) -- s. 87 is BUSINESS-asset-focused with shift-of-establishment requirement.

STATUTORY ARCHITECTURE

ELIGIBILITY: (a) ANY ASSESSEE (individual / HUF / firm / LLP / company) operating INDUSTRIAL UNDERTAKING in URBAN AREA. Distinct from s. 82 / s. 86 (individual / HUF only). (b) ORIGINAL ASSET: machinery / plant / building / land OR rights in building / land used for the business of the urban industrial undertaking. Effectively all CG-eligible assets of the urban factory. (c) SHIFT REQUIREMENT: must be in course of or consequence of SHIFTING the industrial undertaking from urban area TO ANY OTHER AREA (other than urban). The shift-of-establishment requirement (sub-s. 1(b)(iii)) is condition precedent. REINVESTMENT WINDOW (sub-s. 1(b)): 1 YEAR BEFORE OR 3 YEARS AFTER date of original transfer. Wider window than s. 82 / 86 (which allow 1-before / 2-after for purchase) -- recognises industrial relocation complexity. FOUR EXPENDITURE HEADS (sub-s. 1(b)(i)-(iv)): (i) NEW MACHINERY / PLANT for the business of the industrial undertaking in the new area; (ii) Acquired BUILDING / LAND or constructed BUILDING for his business in the new area; (iii) SHIFTED THE ORIGINAL ASSET and transferred ESTABLISHMENT to new area; (iv) Incurred expenses on such OTHER PURPOSE as CG-notified scheme. Aggregate of these = 'new asset' for s. 87 purposes.

MECHANICS / CLAW-BACK

EXEMPTION (sub-s. 1(A)/(B)): (I) IF cost-and-expenses (on heads (i)-(iv)) IS LESS THAN CG: DIFFERENCE chargeable u/s 67; (II) IF cost-and-expenses >= CG: NO CG CHARGED. 3-YEAR CLAW-BACK (sub-s. 1(B)): if new asset transferred within 3 years of being purchased / acquired / constructed / transferred: (a) For (A)(II) full-shielding case: cost of new asset = NIL for subsequent CG computation; (b) For (A)(I) partial-shielding case: cost reduced by amount of CG previously exempt. Effectively s. 82-style claw-back via cost-base reduction. CGAS DEPOSIT (sub-s. 2): if reinvestment incomplete before s. 263 due date, deposit unutilised CG in CGAS-style scheme; submit proof with return; utilise within window. DEEMED COST (sub-s. 3): utilised + deposited = deemed cost of new asset. UTILISATION FAILURE (sub-s. 4): unutilised CGAS at 3-year-expiry charged in expiry year + withdrawal entitlement.

'URBAN AREA' DEFINITION (sub-s. 5)

'Urban area' = any area within limits of MUNICIPAL CORPORATION or MUNICIPALITY, declared as urban area by CG, having regard to: (a) population; (b) concentration of industries; (c) need for proper planning of the area and other relevant factors. CG-notified list of urban areas (CBDT notifications under 1961 s. 54G periodically issued). The definition is administrative -- not all municipal areas are 'urban' for s. 87 purposes; only CG-notified ones. Practitioner: verify the original-undertaking location is CG-notified urban area at the time of transfer; non-notified areas (even if dense) don't qualify.

CASE LAW

(i) Texspin Engineering v. CIT (Bom HC) -- shift-of-establishment test; physical relocation crucial. (ii) ITAT precedents on partial-shift / phased relocation; substantial-shift principle. (iii) CG-notified urban area list updates -- maintain current list reference.

PLANNING NOTES

(i) URBAN AREA VERIFICATION -- verify original undertaking is in CG-notified urban area; obtain CBDT notification copy. (ii) SHIFT-DOCUMENTATION -- document board resolution / state-government NOC / pollution-clearance / new-area land allotment / EPF transfer / employee relocation. (iii) WIDER WINDOW -- 1y before / 3y after; longer than s. 82 / 86; useful for complex industrial relocations. (iv) FOUR-HEAD AGGREGATION -- collate all four heads (plant + building + transfer + CG-scheme expenses) for cost-base maximisation. (v) CGAS DEPOSIT -- before s. 263 due date; designated bank; submit proof. (vi) 3-YEAR HOLDING LOCK -- DO NOT transfer new plant / building within 3 years; cost-reduction claw-back.

CROSS-REFERENCES

  • Section 67 -- CG charge.
  • Section 70 -- Transactions not regarded as transfer.
  • Section 72 -- Mode of computation.
  • Section 88 -- SEZ shifting (parallel s. 54GA).
  • Section 89 -- DVO reference.
  • Section 263 -- Return-filing due date.
  • CGAS-88 scheme.
  • CG notifications listing urban areas.