BharatTax.co — Knowledge Portal
69

ITA 2025 · Section 69

Buyback by Company

Section 69 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 46 A. Sub-section (1) — shareholder is taxed under Capital Gains on (consideration received MINUS cost of acquisition) when company buys back its own shares / specified securities.…

Section 69 — BUYBACK BY COMPANY — CG TREATMENT WITH PROMOTER ADD-ON

Section 69 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 46A. Sub-section (1) — shareholder is taxed under Capital Gains on (consideration received MINUS cost of acquisition) when company buys back its own shares / specified securities. Sub-section (2) (FA 2026 — substituted) — for promoter-shareholders of buybacks under s. 68 of Companies Act, 2013, an ADDITIONAL income-tax applies on top of the regular CG tax — at differential rates for STCG (s. 196) and LTCG (s. 197/198) and split between domestic-company and other-company promoters (Table). Sub-section (3) — promoter definition: SEBI-Buyback-Regulation 2(k) for listed companies; Companies Act 2013 s. 2(69) plus 10%-shareholding test for unlisted.

HISTORICAL CONTEXT — BUYBACK TAX REGIME EVOLUTION

Pre-FA 2024, listed-company buyback was taxed at company level under 1961 s. 115QA at 23.296% (effective) — shareholder receipt was exempt u/s 1961 s. 10(34A). FA 2024 (effective 1-Oct-2024) abolished s. 115QA and shifted incidence to the SHAREHOLDER (treating buyback as deemed-dividend until FA 2025 reverted it to capital-gains). FA 2026 (substituted s. 69(2) and (3)) refines the regime: regular CG-tax PLUS additional promoter-specific tax — to discourage promoter-led buybacks as tax-arbitrage from dividend distribution. Sub-section (3) ensures wide capture of 'promoter' — listed (SEBI) and unlisted (CA + 10% threshold).

STATUTORY ARCHITECTURE

Sub-section (1) — main CG charge: difference between consideration and cost-of-acquisition is CG, in year of buyback. Sub-section (2) — promoter add-on: STCG (held ≤ 12/24/36 months per s. 196) — 2% / 10% (domestic / other promoter); LTCG (s. 197 / 198) — 9.5% / 17.5%. Total tax incidence on promoter = base CG-rate + add-on rate. Sub-section (3) — definitions: (a) listed: SEBI Buyback Regulation 2(k); (b) unlisted: CA-2013 s. 2(69) + 10% direct/indirect shareholding test.

CASE LAW

Cognizant Technology Solutions (Mad HC) — pre-FA 2024 era buyback taxed at company level under s. 115QA; SC stayed; subsequently moot post FA 2024 amendment.

PLANNING NOTES

(i) For listed-company buybacks involving promoter participation, the promoter's effective tax cost can exceed dividend-route — model the differential carefully. (ii) For unlisted-company buybacks, evaluate the 10%-shareholding-promoter test — minor shareholdings may avoid promoter add-on. (iii) Promoter-classification timing — date of buyback offer / acceptance; document SEBI / Registrar filings for tax-position support. (iv) Foreign-promoter (non-resident) — base CG-rate at 12.5% LTCG / treaty rate; add-on at 17.5% LTCG (other-promoter rate); aggregate ≈ 30%. Compare against treaty-based dividend WHT rates.

CROSS-REFERENCES

  • Section 67 / 68 — Capital Gains framework.
  • Section 196 — STCG rate.
  • Section 197 / 198 — LTCG rates.
  • Section 2(40) — Dividend definition (interaction).
  • SEBI Buyback Regulations, 2018.
  • Companies Act, 2013 — s. 68 (buyback) and s. 2(69) (promoter).