BharatTax.co — Knowledge Portal
77

ITA 2025 · Section 77

Slump Sale

Section 77 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 50 B -- the SLUMP SALE computation regime. SLUMP SALE = transfer of an undertaking / division as a GOING CONCERN for a LUMP-SUM CONSIDERATION without item-wise asset valuation ( s. 2 /…

Section 77 — - SLUMP SALE

Section 77 is the substantive equivalent of 1961 s. 50B -- the SLUMP SALE computation regime. SLUMP SALE = transfer of an undertaking / division as a GOING CONCERN for a LUMP-SUM CONSIDERATION without item-wise asset valuation (s. 2 / 1961 s. 2(42C) definition). The provision treats the lump-sum gain as CG (LTCG if undertaking held > 36 months; STCG if 36 months or less). Cost = NET WORTH (assets less liabilities at book value, with revaluation ignored). FVOC = FMV ON TRANSFER DATE per Rule 11UAE (FA 2021 watershed). FIVE sub-sections: (1) LTCG character / chargeability; (2) STCG carve-out for short-held undertakings (36-month test); (3) net-worth-as-cost + FMV-as-FVOC; (4) Form 3CEA accountant's certificate before s. 263 due date; (5) net-worth definition + aggregate-value-of-assets methodology including depreciable-asset WDV / self-generated-goodwill-NIL / s. 46-deductible-NIL / book-value-other-assets.

STATUTORY ARCHITECTURE

SLUMP SALE DEFINITION (s. 2 / 1961 s. 2(42C)): transfer of UNDERTAKING / DIVISION as a GOING CONCERN for a LUMP-SUM consideration without values being assigned to individual assets / liabilities. FA 2021 EXPANSION: 'transfer' for slump-sale purposes includes ANY MEANS of transfer (sale / exchange / relinquishment / extinguishment / similar). Pre-FA 2021 slump-exchange was contested; FA 2021 codified slump-exchange (transferee shares received in exchange for undertaking) as slump sale. CHARACTER (sub-ss. 1-2): (a) DEFAULT: LTCG (undertaking held > 36 months); (b) UNDERTAKING HELD <= 36 MONTHS: STCG. Note: the 36-month period is for the UNDERTAKING (collective business), not individual assets within. So a recently-formed undertaking sold as slump = STCG even if individual assets within are old. COST = NET WORTH (sub-s. 3(a)) -- definition in sub-s. 5(a): Net Worth = Aggregate Value of Total Assets MINUS Value of Liabilities (book-value basis); Revaluation IGNORED (anti-step-up). AGGREGATE VALUE OF TOTAL ASSETS (sub-s. 5(b)): (i) DEPRECIABLE ASSETS: WDV per s. 41(1)(c) -- block-of-assets WDV; (ii) SELF-GENERATED GOODWILL: NIL (codifies B.C. Srinivasa Setty SC); (iii) ASSETS WITH FULL DEDUCTION UNDER s. 46 (R&D etc.): NIL (anti-double-claim); (iv) OTHER ASSETS: BOOK VALUE. FVOC = FMV ON TRANSFER DATE (sub-s. 3(b), FA 2021 watershed): Pre-FA 2021: lump-sum-consideration-actually-received was FVOC; created scope for under-pricing. Post-FA 2021: Rule 11UAE prescribes FMV computation -- HIGHER OF book value (with adjustments) AND consideration. Effectively imposes minimum-FMV floor. FORM 3CEA (sub-s. 4): mandatory CA-certificate computing net worth + certifying correctness; before s. 263 due date.

FA 2021 EXPANSION -- SLUMP EXCHANGE

Pre-FA 2021 controversy: where undertaking transferred IN EXCHANGE for shares of transferee (no monetary consideration), was it a slump sale? Bharat Bijlee (Bom HC), Aerospace Engineering (Mum ITAT) had held 'NO' (slump-exchange outside s. 50B). FA 2021 retrospectively expanded definition to include ALL means of transfer; slump-exchange now squarely within s. 77. Implication: M&A demerger-style structures previously routed through slump-exchange as tax-shelter no longer effective; FMV-as-FVOC ensures CG charged on full economic value.

CASE LAW

(i) Bharat Bijlee Ltd v. ACIT (Bom HC) -- pre-FA 2021 slump-exchange held outside s. 50B; reversed by FA 2021. (ii) PNB Finance Ltd v. CIT (SC, 2008) -- slump sale character; lump-sum consideration test. (iii) CIT v. Aerospace Engineering Pvt Ltd (Mum ITAT) -- slump-exchange controversy. (iv) Triune Energy Services v. CIT (Del HC) -- net-worth methodology / book-value-vs-revaluation. (v) FA 2021 Memorandum -- legislative intent to override Bharat Bijlee.

PLANNING NOTES

(i) UNDERTAKING-VS-ASSET-SALE -- slump sale requires going-concern transfer with all assets-and-liabilities; selective asset sale not slump sale (item-wise CG instead). (ii) FORM 3CEA EARLY -- engage CA 60-90 days before due date; net-worth computation requires extensive book reconciliation. (iii) FMV DETERMINATION -- post-FA 2021, Rule 11UAE methodology applies; engage merchant banker / valuer; FMV often exceeds negotiated consideration in distressed-sale scenarios. (iv) SELF-GENERATED GOODWILL NIL -- preserve evidence of goodwill character; if purchased-goodwill, book value applies. (v) HOLDING PERIOD -- 36 months for UNDERTAKING; date of business commencement / formation, not individual asset acquisition. (vi) LTCG INDEXATION -- post FA 2024, indexation generally unavailable; flat 12.5% applies to slump-sale LTCG.

CROSS-REFERENCES

  • Section 2 -- Slump sale definition (s. 2(42C) of 1961 / s. 2 equivalent).
  • Section 41(1)(c) -- Block-of-assets WDV (referenced in sub-s. 5(b)(i)).
  • Section 46 -- Scientific research expenditure (sub-s. 5(b)(iii)).
  • Section 63 -- Specified date for accountant's report.
  • Section 67 -- CG charge.
  • Section 70(1)(e)/(j) -- Amalgamation / demerger (alternative tax-neutral pathway).
  • Section 72 -- Mode of computation.
  • Section 73 -- Cost in special modes.
  • Section 197 -- LTCG rates (post-FA 2024 12.5%).
  • Income-tax Rules, 2026 r. 11UAE -- FMV computation methodology.
  • Form 3CEA -- accountant's certificate.